Mate Choice and Toxicity in Two Species of Leaf Beetles with Different Types of Chemical Defense

Evidence for the use of defensive compounds for sexual purposes is scarce, even though sexual selection might have some importance for the evolution of defensive traits. This study investigates the effect of defense-related traits and body size on mating success in two sister species of leaf beetle differing in their type of chemical defense. <i>Oreina gloriosa</i> produces autogenous cardenolides, whereas <i>O. cacaliae</i> sequesters pyrrolizidine alkaloids from its food plant. Larger <i>O. gloriosa</i> males with more toxin or higher toxin concentration had a mating advantage, likely due to direct or indirect female choice. In the laboratory, particular pairings recurred repeatedly in this species, indicating mate fidelity. <i>O. gloriosa</i> females were also subject to sexual selection, possibly by male choice, because larger females and those with higher toxin concentration mated more readily and more often. In <i>O. cacaliae</i>, in contrast, sexual selection for toxicity and body size was not detected, or at best was much weaker. Because toxicity is heritable in <i>O. gloriosa</i> but environment-dependent in <i>O. cacaliae</i>, individuals of the former species could be choosing well-defended partners with good genes. Our study suggests that sexual selection may contribute to the maintenance of heritable defensive traits.